Bad versus Worse
Home Up Actual scan

 

SHAW TARGETS ROBERTS' TELEVISION ADS
 
By Brittany Wallman Staff Writer

Congressional candidate Carol Roberts says she stands up to developers. Her opponent, incumbent Congressman Clay Shaw, says she stands up for them. Roberts' new television ad, airing now on broadcast TV in Palm Beach County and on cable in Broward, says she "isn't shy about taking a stand, to manage our growth and protect our kids." It touts her vote for school concurrency, a policy tying classroom growth to residential development.

But Shaw's campaign says the ad is insincere and that Roberts' record on growth is nothing to brag about.

Roberts, the Democratic candidate in the race, accepted at least $55,000 in campaign contributions through June from the development community. Updated contribution lists were due at midnight Tuesday.

Shaw's campaign, pointing to a recent housing development vote, says Roberts does developers' bidding from her seat on the Palm Beach County Commission.

The candidates are battling to represent about 640,000 people in Congressional District 22, which cuts a swath up eastern Broward and Palm Beach counties and pulls in some western communities as well. Roberts ( www.CarolRobertsForCongress.com ), Fort Lauderdale Republican Shaw ( www.ClayShaw.com ), Independent candidate Juan Xuna of Hillsboro Beach ( www.Gr8St8.com ) and write-in candidate Stan Smilan of Lake Worth ( www.StanSmilan.com ) face off Nov. 5 for the two-year term.

Much of the campaign advertising has been geared toward senior issues, particularly the price of prescription drugs, with Roberts urging voters to call her hotline and learn how to buy their prescriptions illegally from Canada. She has embraced a new nickname for herself: "Robin Hood."

But both major candidates have touched on land issues. Shaw ran an Everglades ad. And in Roberts' new "Bigfoot" commercial, airing now in both counties, she is described as tough on developers. The ad says she would, likewise, stand up in Congress to big drug companies and "greedy" executives. "Carol Roberts will put her foot down," the narrator says, "and they're gonna feel it." The camera pans to Roberts' feet; she is wearing combat boots. Shaw's campaign manager says Roberts' development ad is disingenuous.

Larry Casey accused her of "selling off commission votes for campaign contributions" and said the ad belies her spotty development record. The March 2001 concurrency vote she touts in the ad was brought forward by another commissioner and was supported unanimously.

He pointed to Roberts' push in recent months to allow GL Homes to build a 1,500-unit development in Palm Beach County's Agricultural Reserve. The company, which contributed $5,000 to Roberts' congressional campaign, needed a change in the county's comprehensive plan to spill its main entrance traffic onto Acme Dairy Road instead of Boynton Beach Boulevard.

Roberts pushed to get that approved. Her campaign said the deal worked well for the county, which received park and school land in return.

"What she did was to bring GL Homes and the environmentalists to the table to discuss the issues, and the environmentalists will tell you they got everything they wanted out of the deal she brokered," said Stephen Gaskill, Roberts' spokesman. 

"It's only because we did all the work," counters Joanne Davis, community planner for the environmental group 1,000 Friends of Florida, who said Roberts' environmental record has been "awful" lately. "The commissioners were ready to roll over on it."

Roberts also recently jumped in to aid Catalfumo Construction, when it was second-ranked on a $35 million county contract. In July, she supported giving the contract to Catalfumo, whose president, Daniel Catalfumo, had given her $1,000 in June.

She rejected the top-ranked firm, Centex Rooney Construction Co., whose officials had given $1,500 to Shaw this year.

Roberts has assailed Shaw for taking more than $72,000 in campaign contributions from pharmaceutical companies over two election cycles. She contends that Shaw is benefiting from an ad campaign, which Roberts says cost $1.3 million, by United Seniors Association, a conservative group partly bankrolled by drug companies. She's also railed against his acceptance of money from Enron Corp. and other troubled corporations before their problems surfaced, and from the Arthur Andersen accounting firm in elections dating to 1989. She says the contributions show Shaw is in the pocket of those who gave the money. The same can be said of her and developers, Casey said.

"I would say if she thinks she's Robin Hood, then if the Sherwood Forest were in Palm Beach County she would pave over it and turn it into a parking lot," he said.

Brittany Wallman can be reached at BWallman@Sun-Sentinel.com  or 954-356-4541.

 

 

New Address: Stuart, FL 34997Phn: (772) 324-1123,   Fax:(561) 210-1370,  Email: Xuna@MSN.com 

"LEGACY WEBSITE": Will remain unaltered for foreseeable future.